Scott Pilgrim vs. The Audiences

What can I say about Scott Pilgrim? I don’t know what I can say. This review will be glowing. I loved it. But what else can be said? Can I even say anything to make you think that I am not just a fanboy (is that even such a bad thing?)? Well, I guess I can defend myself my saying that I saw the film without having read the graphic novels first. In fact, I didn’t even really know the movie was based on a set of graphic novels until the film was nearly released. I guess that is some defense. But I’d have to admit that in a span of several (five?) weeks after I first saw SPvTW that I had read all six graphic novels. I guess my cover is blown. So you can believe what I’m about to say or you can just dismiss it as a love letter; but I hope that you don’t. I truly believe everything I’m about to say and I do believe that I’m looking at this as objectively as I can. And be forewarned, I am going to make some pretty strong statements.

I have not yet read the graphic novel The Crow, though I have flipped through it. The Brandon Lee movie looks to be pretty faithful to the source, but having not read the source material fully I will pass on any judgment at this time. Having said all that, I believe Scott Pilgrim vs. The World to be the most faithful film adaptation of a graphic novel that I have ever seen. Wow. I know, right? It’s up against such stalwarts such as Superman, the various Batman films, Spiderman, X-Men, and the Frank Miller inspired films Sin City and 300. All but the last two probably could’ve stood on their own without the graphic novel. If we lived in a world with no Superman, and someone made the 1978 film from an original idea, I still believe that it would have been a great action movie. Can a comic book movie that stands on its own legs be a great adaption? In some ways sure, but it can lose the feel of the comic book. Sin City and 300 are interesting cases, however. Those were made specifically to replicate the look of a graphic novel on screen. And they did. But the creativity came in how the look was recreated.
The reason why I feel this is the most faithful recreation is not because it is reproduced word for word or that the scenes are exact. In fact, there are times when the dialogue said by someone in the graphic novel is said by someone else entirely in the film. And in a different part of the story. But it works. It is still funny or poignant. The original intent of that line is not lost.

The graphic novels and the movie are full of action, full of humor, and full of emotion. Sometimes the best way to cut to the core of an issue is to use humor and action. And these things use humor and action to great effect.

We’ve all been there. We’ve all broken up with someone. Sometimes it’s for dumb reasons, such as “We were in high school and she had freckles.” Other times we break up with someone because we feel it’s the right thing to do. Sometimes we are cheated on and are the dumped. And it hurts. Even when that happens to us we don’t always realize that we’ve done similar things to others and hurt them too. Sometimes we let our ego get in our own way, and other times we realize that someone is worth the fight.

Ultimately, this, like the graphic novels before it, is just a different interpretation of video games. One of the many successes of this project is the style in which it was completed. Before each “boss battle” there is a “versus” shot that is reminiscent of Virtua Fighter or Tekken games. Scott receives points and coins for each boss and baddie that he defeats. Zelda is referenced to on several occasions. Japanese animation is also referenced in this movie, also to great effect. The fight scenes are superbly choreographed (even the always nerdy looking Jonathan Schwartzmann gets into the act) and the soundtrack is an important part of the movie. More on style, whenever the drummer for Scott’s band yells the cadence “One! Two! Three! Four!” you see text above her. That’s just one example of things found in the movie, and another reminds me of Star Wars. In those classic George Lucas films, whenever two lightsabers met in battle there was a brief flash of light inserted into the frame. It was imperceptible yet drew attention to the fight that was occurring. A similar thing happens when to combatants meet in this movie.

Some have criticized the movie for playing to a younger crowd. I honestly don’t think this is true. Most of the video game and pop culture references will be beyond the experiences of today’s teens and it’s my opinion that most of those references will be understood best by those in their late twenties or in their thirties. It pays tribute to arcade and 8-bit games more than any young person today could recognize.

In my opinion, this is Edgar Wright’s best film. It’s his pièce de résistance. Although all of his works have drawn heavily on other sources, this is the only one that is truly based on something else. Yet it feels like it original. Yes, many of the costumes and set pieces and obviously dialogue and stories are drawn from the novels; but he did not slavishly recreate scenes or dialogue. He made it his own. In many ways taking something that already exists and making it your own is more difficult than creating something new. What more can I saw about this movie except that it rocked my world?

Well, I told you that I loved this movie; maybe too much to be objective about it. But that’s OK. If you can’t geek out once in a while then what’s the point?
My rating is 10/10. That’s right. Full score. I admittedly think that it is the best movie I’ve seen this year.